Skip to main content

Helping with RMD’s, Charity and Long-Term Care

September 13, 2024

Background:

In 2020, Tom had a choice about whether to take a required minimum distribution, or “RMD” from his IRA account. Because of Covid-19, the government had given retirees a reprieve—they could go ahead and take an RMD in 2020 or not. Tom had other sources of income: his social security, his wife, Allie’s, Social Security, and funds they could take from a lower-tax, non-qualified account.

How We Helped:

Tom’s required minimum distributions had started just the year before, in 2019, and that year, like this one, we were trying to time the RMD in relation to a Roth Conversion from Tom’s IRA. A Roth Conversion allows someone to move funds from their IRA account to a Roth IRA account, choosing to pay tax now rather than later. Why would someone choose to do that? They might think tax rates will be going up, as Tom did, or that their beneficiaries will face a higher tax bracket. They also might want to lower their Traditional IRA account value to reduce future RMDs as a result of the conversion.. Once someone begins taking RMDs, a Roth Conversion is only allowed once their RMD for the year has already been taken. And here were Tom’s choices. Was he going to take an RMD this year? Was he going to do a Roth Conversion?

After much discussion, Tom elected NOT to take an RMD in 2020, but to do a more significant Roth Conversion. Our thinking was simple: the best time to convert funds is when they have been depressed; that way, the likely rebound will take place in the tax-free Roth IRA. You get more bang for your buck by doing it this way and, having decided against taking an RMD, Tom could go ahead and do a Roth Conversion while the market was down. We moved some of the more aggressive investments Tom had in his IRA over to his Roth IRA in early April, in plenty of time to enjoy the strong stock market rebound from the pandemic low.

The work is never done, though—there’s always maintenance, up-keep, and as Tom and Allie became more invested in their community, they wanted to give to local charities. This, interestingly enough, also impacted their IRAs. In addition to taking an RMD each year, and determining whether Tom wanted to do a Roth Conversion, we also discussed “qualified charitable distributions” or QCDs. A QCD allows an IRA holder who is at least 70.5 to give to charity directly from an IRA, satisfying part or all of their RMD depending on the size of the gift, without having to pay tax on the amount that goes to charity. In effect, a person can make the charitable contributions they were going to anyways, but use the IRA to do so, satisfying part, or all, of their RMD in the process. For a couple like Tom and Allie, who really didn’t need the RMD for income, this was a great strategy.

Tom and Allie’s Long-Term Care policy has also required some maintenance in retirement. Like so many Long-Term Care policy holders, Tom and Allie and have seen the premiums increase on their policies since they bought them in 2008. In 2020, their insurance company came back asking for a second, additional increase to the premium.  In cases where the insurance company sees dramatically higher future costs than they anticipated, they can go to each state’s insurance commissioner and seek permission to increase premiums.  If they can demonstrate this is necessary for their solvency, then they get the go-ahead.  In the policies we work with, we’ve seen this happen, on average, every 5-7 years, and Tom and Allie faced this situation again in 2020.

We did a review of their options—to pay the higher premium, to reduce their coverage and keep the premium the same, or to reduce future cost of living increases on the policies.  Armed with our research, Tom and Allie could see that if they do, in fact, need care, the additional cost of paying premium on the full policy value will likely be more than covered by savings within the first year they need the coverage. In other words, as long as they could afford to pay the additional premium, it likely made sense to do so. Tom and Allie decided that they would accept this premium increase, but we agreed to analyze any future premium increase with a similar rigor.

Tom and Allie worked hard for the retirement they wanted. The guidance that we provide builds on, and protects, the work that they did to get there.

The above case study is hypothetical and for informational purposes only. Case Studies illustrate the hypothetical experience of a fictitious client based on a scenario that an actual client might experience. The Case Studies are designed to generally illustrate how we may provide our services to our clients. None of the Case Studies should be construed by a client or prospective client as a guarantee that he/she will experience a certain level of results or satisfaction if Zeniki is engaged, or continues to be engaged, to provide investment advisory services.